Sunday, 13 November 2011

Myth Busted - Citadel colour mixing



For months now colour mixing charts are circulating on the web about a great chunk of the current Citadel range being possible to be replicated by simply mixing Skull White, Chaos Black, Blood Red, Enchanted Blue and Sunburst Yellow in the right proportions.
The story surfaced first at Nesbet Miniatures Blog and months later on the excellent Path of the Outcast Blog that I'm following. After sharing my concerns; Cannonfodder, the blog owner started a poll, asking the public what they think. 54% voted that they didn't try it but they thought it would work.
Actually it doesn't.
When I first read the original post at Nesbet's blog I shared the enthusiasm with all the rest, but after a little while things started to distub me a little.

A little on colours

For three years or so I was an active (and now honorary) member of Europa Barbarorum a project that some of you may know. It is a hardcore total realism mod for Rome (and later Medieval) Total War. Apart from skinning a few dozens of units in the mod, I was making some research into dyes and pigments, and how they work. (It was important to know what colours could be produced in the timeframe, and what was cheap or expensive.)
A colour has three major attributes: hue, saturation and lightness. It is possible to produce any colour by mixing rays of light in different colour, basically any hue can be recreated this way. What works with light doesn't work with pigments though. Pigments are of different opacity and will not produce all the hues you want. Of course I mean the pigments we modellers use; the cyan-magenta-yellow system for offset printing is an entirely different matter, and even there colours are not mixed, only dots (I know it is a bit more complex then this).
The other important thing is saturation. It is the measure how vivid the colour is. Pastel colours have more gray in them so they are of lower saturation.
The third thing to be taken into consideration is that pigments have personality... some hues you just cannot produce by mixing them. The best example is purple. In the antiquity a few grams of purple dye could feed a family for decades. Don't you think it was easier to mix or overdye madder and woad or indigo? It just did not work. Only purple dye did the job.
The charts don't, or very little address these points and this is the reason why they fail miserably.

The proof

No research is complete without experiment though, and it was relative easy - as all my readers know - I keep my citadel paints in dropper bottles. This time apart from cropping I did not use any Photoshop goodies and let the image much bigger then usual.
The results speak for themselves:


As ever, I don't pretend to have a monopoly for the truth, so if you thik that the colours are good enough proxies, or I did something wrong and you had different results, please do not hesitate to comment!
But from my part: Mith Busted.

8 comments:

  1. thanks for the background and for the experiment. Funny thing aside: I was also skinner and modeler for computer games for years. I will write a follow up on the issue and show your results if it is okay for you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sure it is! the point is to help people prevent the mistakes we make :-). My diminishing stock of citadel colours gave these results, someone with different colours may fare better, but I for one very much doubt it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. TY for this,

    Can you just clarify your swatch please?

    WM

    ReplyDelete
  4. Eh... What swatch? Please excuse me English is not my native tongue... The colours are on a plain white paper, the lighting is with daylight bulbs, the camera is on direct daylight setting. No digital alteration apart from cropping.
    Is that what you asked?

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dinh Duong tốt cho sức khỏe của bạn và điệu trị một số bệnh tiểu đường, cao huyết áp, tim mạch, viêm khớp, loãng xương, dinh duong Một chế độ dinh duong hợp lý sẽ giúp bé yêu của bạn phát triển cân đối. Ăn cá giàu chất dinh duong axít béo omega-3 hai lần mỗi tuần để cung cấp vitamin giúp não phát triển và hoạt động tốt. Nếu có thể, hãy chọn ăn loại cá có hàm lượng che do dinh duong thủy ngân thấp hoặc không chứa thủy ngân, chẳng hạn như cá hồi và cá trích. Ăn nhiều rau xanh giàu chat dinh duong như cải bó xôi, bông cải xanh... có tác dụng giữ cho não sắc bén nhờ chúng chứa hàm lượng axít folic cao.

    ReplyDelete

  6. i like this post, we visit again for more updates , thanks for sharing this article.
    cheap artificial grass

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sorry for being 5 years late with this response: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1z8NQoTemsc

    Now, I do suspect that somebody just calculated the mixing recipes from additive (computer screen) colour mixing, and pigments do work a little different, but you can still mix any colour as long as you start with Process yellow, process magenta, process cyan, white and black.

    ReplyDelete